« Atlantic Yards Showdown Over the Slowdown | Main | Tale of two rallies »
May 10, 2008
Tale of two renderings
The Brooklyn Paper
Gersh Kuntzman
Atlantic Yards developer Bruce Ratner and his foes presented starkly different visions for the mega-project this week — one, a scaled-back, Frank Gehry wonderland, the other, a collection of bulky buildings and a basketball arena surrounded for decades by parking lots.Fittingly, the rival visions were published on Monday in rival newspapers, with the Daily News trumpeting the new Gehry renderings and the New York Post playing up the Municipal Art Society’s far-less-glamorous vision in its own exclusive, “The future’s ‘blight’; Nightmare vision of B’klyn arena.”
The Society said it was moved to create the doomsday renderings because Ratner himself has admitted that the 16-tower Atlantic Yards project now contains only two confirmed structures: a residential building and a publicly financed $950-million basketball arena that he intends to begin building before the end of 2008.
The memorable quote in this article comes from Architect Errol Crawford, with language evoking an art piece from Donald O'Finn:
“I think the new design looks like student work at best,” he said. “It is a shame the amount of money being spent on crap like that. I realize that Gehry’s signature is deconstructivist architecture, but his elevations [an architecture term meaning “exterior views”] suck.“The Williamsburgh Savings Bank building should not have to look down at a clogged toilet bowl every morning,” he added.
Posted by amy at May 10, 2008 12:19 PM