« As vows fade in Atlantic Yards, so do housing hopes | Main | Ratner’s lies »

March 23, 2008

Daily News columnists Louis, Daly lament AY setbacks, blame NIMBYs, avoid facts

Atlantic Yards Report offers a take-down of today's not-so-fact-filled articles in the Daily News. Following is the Errol Louis version of the Atlantic Yards job situation followed by Atlantic Yards Report's corrections:

That's just fine with the anti-development brigade. Here are the words of one of their number, a man named Joe Boms, who sent a note to me last month that he said reflected the thoughts of his Park Slope neighbors.

"I'm afraid 100 jobs - or 10,000 jobs - are not reason enough. A monster of such scope and complexity simply does not belong in the downtown area," wrote Boms. "We do indeed wish that financiers, insurers, investors and its plethora of assorted cheerleaders will pull out, and let this white elephant die in a spectacular way so as to serve as a lesson to future megalomaniacs."

That kind of smug willingness to condemn others to joblessness is infuriating.

Louis's smug willingness to ignore facts is more infuriating. Remember, Ratner initially promised 10,000 office jobs, as likely as the Easter Bunny. The claimed 15,000 construction jobs would be 1500 jobs a year over ten years.

As for condemning others to joblessness, note that most of the office jobs--however many there might be--would likely be relocated rather than new. Yes, a good chunk of the demolition and construction jobs would go to locals under the CBA--35% Minority and 10% women construction workers, with efforts (though not guarantees) to hire locally.


Posted by amy at March 23, 2008 1:34 PM