« On My Command Unleash Ribs | Main | Ridge Hill hearings »

April 30, 2006

What would Jane Jacobs say? Disingenuousness & Atlantic Yards


AtlanticYardsReport looks at what Jane Jacobs would have thought about the Atlantic Yards proposal:

I'd speculate that Jacobs, like some Brooklynites, would approach Forest City Ratner's Atlantic Yards project with some ingrained skepticism, based on the developer's much-criticized architecture and urban design at MetroTech, the Atlantic Center mall, and the Atlantic Terminal mall. (Photo at right of MetroTech on a Saturday afternoon, by Brian Carreira for the Brooklyn Rail.)

She might have worried that the project would create a superblock, with the closing of Pacific Street between Carlton and Vanderbilt avenues. She might not have been as conclusory as the WNYC caller about how the project cuts off neighborhoods--project proponents point out that the sunken railyard also cuts off neighborhoods, which is why development of some sort makes sense.


Posted by amy at April 30, 2006 10:31 AM